“In Her Shoes” is a romantic perfect fit
With close-ups of chic high heels pervading the opening credits and hearing the sassy rock song “Stupid Girl” by Garbage, “In Her Shoes” appears to be yet another gratuitous helping of girlish exuberance and fluff. Fortunately, the film evolves far beyond what it first seems to be. It conveys a story about the relationship of two sisters, yes. But it’s also a story about an entire family and the challenging relationships that they experience together.
To the inevitable dismay, and presumable delight of some viewers, Cameron Diaz (“Vanilla Sky”) does plenty of strutting around with her flawless skin covered in tiny bits of cloth. But she clearly proves there is significant substance underneath her smooth curves. Diaz plays Maggie, an irresponsible party girl whose lifestyle consists of barhopping and bed hopping. When she is forced to move in with her stiff, hardworking sister, Rose (Toni Collette, “Connie and Carla”), the clashing begins as the ladies drive each other mad with their opposing personalities. These scenes of clashing provide moments of humor as well as heartbreak, forcing Rose to kick Maggie to the curb.
As the sisters go on living their lives separate from one another, they gradually end up living in a manner opposite from what they have always done. Both of these characters are wonderfully compelling as they begin to experience life in “each other’s shoes” but still retain their relatable personas. Diaz is convincing and effective but it is Collette who truly shines above all others in this film. The unsure, reclusive lawyer she portrays is perfect as she progressively reveals wounded emotions. Hopefully, this graceful performance will finally make her a household name.
Equally graceful is Shirley MacLaine (“Bewitched”), whose effortless portrayal as the sisters’ estranged grandmother brings strong realism and subtle humor to the film. MacLaine’s particular relationship with Diaz creates an enlightening juxtaposition of old and new generations and the indisputable fact that the word ‘family’ means more than having a roof over your head.
The encompassing theme of family bonds presented by the sisters’ relationship is sure to touch the hearts of many female viewers. Can sisters grow separately from each other without growing apart? This film offers a surprisingly poignant answer. Much of this surprise is due to the fact that this film isn’t shallow or cheesy; it displays credible depth and emotion. Although some of the plot developments are predictable, the movie as a whole creates a beautiful story about love, forgiveness and honesty.
The success of the story is due primarily to Jennifer Weiner, who wrote the 2005 novel of the same title on which this film is based. But just because the film is mostly about females does not mean that men should skip out on viewing it. These heartfelt messages of family can be enjoyed by men just as much as women. And for those of us who loathe and cherish our families at the same time, this shoe fits impeccably.
Casey T. Allen is a movie critic for the Utah Statesman. Comments can be sent to him at
caseyal@cc.usu.edu